This is a very informative article written by Charles Wardell from Professional Deck Builders Magazine about thermally modified wood with a product overview as a decking alternative to tropical hardwoods like Ipe including an overview of the Pros and Cons associated to the wood.
Thermally modified wood, also called heat-treated wood, has been available since the mid-1990s in Europe, where it was developed as an environmentally friendly alternative to tropical hardwoods. It’s relatively new to North America, though, and its lack of a track record makes a lot of builders hesitant to try it. With that in mind, we decided to take a closer look at the material and talk with some professionals who do have experience using it.
The decking is sold and priced as a premium product. The suppliers and deck builders we spoke with say that thermally treated ash costs as much as or a bit more than ipe, depending on the market. Southern yellow pine is priced on par with cedar.
To be happy with this product, it’s important to adjust your expectations about weathering. Users find that it grays dramatically faster than any other wood. “The heat-treated southern yellow pine starts out a golden brown and the ash a dark chocolate brown, but they both turn color within three months.”
Pros and Cons
To be happy with this product, it’s important to adjust your expectations about weathering. Bartnik finds that it grays dramatically faster than any other wood. “The heat-treated southern yellow pine starts out a golden brown and the ash a dark chocolate brown, but they both turn color within three months.”
For some this is a deal breaker. “It’s true that all wood turns gray eventually,” says Mike McKay, a Wasaga Beach, Ontario, deck and dock builder who built a 750-square-foot deck from heat-treated southern yellow pine three years ago. “But if I’m spending that kind of money on a deck product, I want it to look good for a long time.” McKay reports that the decking he purchased wasn’t prefinished or sealed, which he suspects may have contributed to its rapid weathering (he applied an oil finish to the deck after installation). Most thermally modified decking is now prefinished and sealed prior to delivery.
According to McKay, the surface weathering didn’t impact the structural integrity of the decking; in fact, the boards showed no signs of decay, checking, or movement. But after being pressure-washed, sanded, and refinished, the boards quickly turned gray again.
For other contractors, the color change is a nonissue. One of these is Jim Smith, project manager with Mark Tanner Construction, in Truckee, Calif., who has built 20 decks with the Thermory product. Truckee’s 6,000-foot elevation in the Sierra Nevada mountains puts all materials under severe UV exposure. “It doesn’t matter what you use,” he says. “The UV here is so strong that everything grays.”
One solution is proper field treatment with an oil-based preservative. It must be oil-based because the wood doesn’t absorb water. Smith uses Cutek Extreme, a high-performance wood protector with a UV inhibitor that’s imported from Australia. It forestalls graying for up to a year, after which the boards can be pressure-washed and re-treated. EcoVantage’s Holman recommends a product called Seal It Green Xtreme, a stain/sealer specially formulated for thermally treated wood. He says that a tint can be added that will extend the color life on decking for as long as three years.
Smith finds that the material holds up well to temperature swings. “In the spring, temperatures can range from 15°F in the morning to almost 90°F during the day,” he says. “Other decking products can expand and contract up to 3/4 inch with these temperature swings, but Thermory doesn’t move at all.”
One reason Smith prefers the ash product is because of its hardness. “When we have heavy snow years, products like ipe and synthetic decking get nicked and scratched by the snow removal process,” adds Smith. “Thermory ash stands up a lot better.”
Other contractors mention the same benefits that Weston Premium Woods’ James does. For instance, Toronto deck builder Rosario Ungaro used Thermory on a porch two years ago. Like a lot of builders, he was hesitant at first. “I saw it at the International Builders Show in Las Vegas,” he recalls. “I was skeptical, but our client wanted to try it out.” It turned out to be a good decision. He recently returned to inspect the porch and immediately noticed that none of the boards had moved. “With most woods, the miter joints would have started to separate, but we didn’t see any of that,” he says.
He says the material was a pleasure to use. “You do have to pre-drill before fastening, but it’s generally great to work with when compared with an exotic wood like ipe,” he says. “Cutting is extremely easy because there are no resins or sugars in the wood. In fact, it leaves tools and blades clean, with no gumming.” Also, the wood comes out of the kiln about 30% lighter, making it easier to handle.
Speaking of handling, Ungaro names a benefit that none of the manufacturers identify: “Our guys don’t have an itchy sensation like they do when using some of the exotic woods.”
You can read the full Charles Wardell article by clicking on “Full Article”